![]() |
| My best friend and I were in youth group and went on a mission trip together. |
Dear Old Friend,
You were not just my friend. You were one of my best friends. In the time we spent together, we often spoke of our aspirations, dreams, as well as the prayers we had for our community. Fast forward to the present, and much has changed. It was only last Fall when we saw one another for the first time in 12 years. It was too long to be silent. Nevertheless, I understand why the hesitancy to speak. If I was struggling with something as you had been, I think I may have hidden myself as well.
Actually, I did hide. Best friends, but I guess we both had our secrets. And I wonder why neither of us felt safe enough to say something. At least to each other. I struggled with suicidal idealizations; you struggled with same-sex attractions. I remember there was a moment that you hinted to it. “I am attending the GSA to be a light to that community.” When we were on a mission trip, you honed in on the outreaches to the LGBT+ youth. I guess I should have figured it out. But honestly? Jesus loves people who struggle in those areas, so I never assumed you had struggled with it yourself. I thought God just put a passion in your heart for those people.
There are times people can pinpoint attributes or personalities that prove, as evidence, someone being gay. Maybe I’m a little slow. Maybe I need more forthwith communication, but in the years we shared, it never crossed my mind. You were just my friend. You had such a loving, carefree personality. So creative, and a wonderful smile. You were colorful, but I never took that as meaning you liked boys. Is there such a thing as a “gay personality”? The thought seems almost repulsive. As if to say, when people act a certain way, that “must” mean they are not straight.
But the truth is - you came out as gay soon after graduating high school. I remember hearing it from my mom…who heard it from her best friend who has a tendency to gossip. Golly, I wish I had heard it from you. Why didn’t you come to me, yourself? Why didn’t you tell me you were struggling? Why did you just cut me off for more than a decade? However, I wondered if I would have judged you. I probably wouldn’t have hated you. But being a fix-it person, and a misstep in sexuality would have been something I probably would’ve started to brainstorm to assist with. “If we just get this thing figured out, then you’ll be just fine.”
From my observations, you feel fine, nonetheless. If I shared this letter with you, Friend, you probably would say there is nothing to fix. I realize that after time has written some of our chapters, we are found more likely to sit at opposite sides of the table, rather than next to one another. Where once we found a bond in our love for Jesus, I wonder if the same could be said now.
I know that we now disagree on whether acting on same-sex attraction is a sin or not. But I bet it is disheartening to see how Christians are so quick to want to fix this particular sin but fail to address other infractions of God’s Word. If homosexuality is such a big deal, then why isn’t adultery, or pride, or gossip, or hatred? Sometimes the way Christians talk about “heathens”, one would wonder if we really believe that Jesus loves them and has truly extended His grace towards them.
Worse, many Christians have treated those a part of the LGBT+ community as if they were blanket projects. Maybe I am guilty of this. I’m sorry. I’m so sorry. We demand you to repent of your sin, without seeing your humanity. We are bent on debating theology without asking for your story. And if I ever communicated this attitude when we were teenagers, I am so sorry. I don’t know if I would have been willing to ask the questions that needed to be asked. And I write this letter in a blog - but it may not ever be shared - because though I want to communicate my care and love that never ceased - I don’t know if it would lay open wounds you already tried to forget. “Let’s agree to disagree and move on.” But I don’t know if I can truly move on. Because when you came out, suddenly I had questions.
What is your story, my dear friend? When did you start having same-sex attractions? Did you go to anyone in the church? If you did, what was their response? Did you try to talk to me, and did I give off an air that I was unwilling to listen?
I know that many statistics show those who are gay more likely were abused. But I also know that isn’t 100% true. Sometimes, people have these feelings only because they have had them (i.e., not really any other explanation as to why). Old school way of the church dealing with things was either confronting it or not talking about it at all. If we don’t mention it, then they are likely to not deal with the topic. Somehow, I can bet that you could reprove that quite quickly. Maybe you knew about my fix-it personality. Maybe you figured - and perhaps correctly - that if you tried telling me your story that I would have tried to fix you.
When all you really needed was a friend to listen, and to love you, nonetheless. And you might be disappointed to hear that I still fall for the idea “If he was just straight, then things would turn out.” As if your sexuality is the most important thing about you. I’m sorry for being so fixated on one attribute of your life. Even if we agreed that homosexuality is a sin, would I be willing to address the questions of loneliness and love that are so often asked? Would I demand that you HAVE to be celibate with no reward in life? Or if you just got with a woman, then that would fix all your problems.
Yeah, right.
I think I am realizing that this isn't how it works. And homosexuality isn’t the unforgivable sin. And even if you became straight, it isn’t like it fixes all other problems. Just because I stopped wishing for death doesn’t mean I didn’t have other sins I needed to work through. I’m sorry that we, as Christians, have made sexuality the entrance test for accepting the grace afforded for us by Jesus. I am sorry that we can so often look down on those in the LGBT+ community, regarding their lives as too dirty to love. I’m sorry we have become Pharisees in the modern age.
I wish we were willing to tell you that Jesus loves you. No matter what. Jesus died for all of you. And it wasn’t just to address one aspect of your lives. At this moment, I wonder if many would argue that sexuality isn’t even something to fix. This can get into another discussion, one perhaps done in person…but I will say this. Whatever changes occur in your life, it is because of Jesus; it will be Him doing the work, not any other person.
I am done trying to fix you. I just want you to know that I love you. That never stopped even when we failed to speak. Jesus loves you. I don’t know if you still speak with Him or put your faith in Him. Maybe you have totally given up on Jesus. Maybe He’s your Savior, or He is just a profound teacher to you. No matter how you think of Him, He loves you and wants a relationship with you. Again, I apologize for how the church has communicated in one way or another that you would have to change before God accepts you. But whatever transformation is to take place in your life will never be done on your own efforts, or another adjacent human being. It can only be made manifest by the power of the Holy Spirit.
I hope someday, you feel welcome coming home. And I pray that we (the church) would celebrate the sight of your face instead of waiting for you to comply with our demands. For if we demand you to change your sexuality before accepting Jesus’ grace, then we better expect of ourselves to change our habits before crying out to Him to be our Savior. But that would defeat the purpose of Him earning our salvation, wouldn’t it?
I will admit, coming to Jesus, you may have to wrestle again. You will be forced to face the questions of your sexuality. But so have I for any sexual temptations I have had. The reason I am discussing the sexuality component in depth, now, is because - from what I have seen - sexuality has become a source of identity. Frankly, all of us hold onto something that we define ourselves by. I know that I have defined myself by my disability, my childhood wounds. I have said, “I will not move forward until….” this person changes, or my circumstances progress. In my walk with Jesus, there are some things He has told me to let go and trust. It has been scary, but He is also showing me that He isn’t leaving my side. It won’t be easy, and after so many years of achieving a victory in standing on your own ground, for me to suggest laying it all down may come across as an insult. I do not mean to offend. And if you choose to come back home, I promise I’ll be there.
I cannot promise I will fully understand. I may say things that rub the wrong way. I admit I have a bias. But never will I hate you. And though I may be ignorant, I hope I am not arrogant. I guess it has taken me a bit of time to write all of this, but in summation it comes down to this: I miss you, brother. And I wish only God’s best for you. In the words of Dolly Parton*,
If I should stay,
I would only be in your way.
So, I’ll go, but I know
I will think of you each step of the way.
And I will always love you.
I will always love you.
Bittersweet memories
That’s all I’m taking with me.
Goodbye, please don’t cry.
We both know that I’m not what you need.
I hope life treats you kind.
And I hope you have all
That you dreamed of.
And I wish you joy and happiness,
But above all, I wish you love.
Sincerely,
Laura Emily
*Dolly Parton – I will always love you lyrics | genius lyrics. (n.d.). Retrieved March 8, 2023, from https://genius.com/Dolly-parton-i-will-always-love-you-lyrics





